Moving from P&S to dSLR?
After five years of faithful use, I finally decided to give my Canon A80 a rest. When I initially purchased it was just for casual shooting during trips with friends. I didn't imaging that I'd get this intrested in Photography. Canon's legendary A80 when it was first introduced was, one of the best in the P&S range. While staying in the P&S range, it allowed one to experiment a bit with Apreture & Shutter Priority, a very limited manual mode as well. At the time it was introduced,there where a very few camera's that allowed that. As such over 5 years of use, my A80 has stayed very useful and was worth every penny I paid. After 4.5 years the sensor went bad. Imagine my surprise when Canon offered to do a free replacement & service for it owing to an humidity issue they'd discovered 3 years earlier. I'm not used to such service centers in India & B'lore. No questions asked, they replaced the faulty sensor & returned the camera well in shape and in time. (All this for a camera they'd long since discontinued!). So when I decided to get a dSLR, I had decided on Canon although I'm well aware the Nikons are better in IQ.
Deciding on a dSLR has been a very difficult choice. The consumer is spoiled for choice. I nearly spent about a month surveying it all and finally ended up purchasing the Canon T1i.
Here a few pointers for those moving from the P&S range to dSLR. My main points of consideration where:
* Size. (Hey, no point in buying a dSLR if you find yourself avoiding it on casual trips because of its size)
* Image Quality. (A comparison at various ISO levels)
* Service options. (Its a big investment, this is definitely not an non-issue)
* Video
* lenses
* filters & accessories.
* bag
* a good tripod
Some elaboration:
Size: One of the coolest things about a P & S is that it would fit into your pocket and because it so small you don't mind carrying it out with friends on a trip. For dSLR, if you are going to the mid-range or pro ones, they are quite some baggage. Even entry level ones can be quite big compared to a dSLR. I choose the T1i over the Nikon because it was about 30% smaller and less heavy. For me size was a deal breaker issue. I know will not carry it around if its too big. One other thing to consider is that if the equipment looks intimidating, you may have places in India where they'll not let you take snaps. Once I'd borrowed my friends S2 IS and was shooting at Kanagadurga Temple (AP), out of nowhere a cop came and asked me to stop, saying that professional photography was disallowed. As long as I was shooting with the A80, there were no objections, because of its size, they think you are just normal tourist. I had to convince that guy with my id card to prove I wasn't a photographer!
Image Quality:
In this department, the Nikons win hands down. The difference is not too much. but still the Nikons are visibly better. Nevertheless for me the size swung my decision to the Canon T1i. (On hindsight now, though, I feel I shouldn't have compromised this. I find the T1i noise levels are often very high).
Service Centers:
I've narrated my experience with Canon above. So this was Canon for me hands down.
Video:
A small incident is worth a mention here:
I never did think I'll ever want to take video, but this changed after my nephew was born. I had a k500i mobile which has a pretty bad camera and Video. For over 3 years I ended up taking candid videos of him doing things right from Ages 3-5. Since the mobile was always there with me, I could just shoot when I pleased. Besides viewing it was also a breeze, you didn't have to setup a TV et all. When we used to wait for bus or something, often I'd play the videos and everyone in the family enjoyed watching. One fine day, I lost the phone. People at home teased me that it was about time I upgraded. But then later when it struck home that it was not just the phone that was gone but also all those videos, we were very sorry, for my nephew is now 7. See my point? Even though the phones video is pretty bad, just the availablity of the option makes you take videos. Later you might find that such things are priceless. So I was quite keen on having video on my DSLR too.
dSLRs have now begun to come with HiDef Video! The T1i represents a leap in technology, its integrated HiDef Video is another main factor that swung my decision to it. Beware though, the video has problems, It picks up lense focus noise which can be quite distracting. Also the Hidef recording speed is quite slow, so for anything that involves panning and some speed, it probably won't do. But nevertheless, the T1i was about a 100$ more expensive that the Xsi and I didn't want to loose the option of an integrated video recorder for $100. As I said, I don't like lugging a lot of baggage around (which I'd have to do if I got a cam corder. This is no match to a camcoder although the ability to change lenses might seem good. Hey but still, once in a while you might take off to a trip without plans to do video and you can never say when you'll find a few things worth preserving.) May be I'll not use the video, but still who knows? I didn't want to loose the option of video for a mere 4k rs extra. Hell, if my nephew's videos where any indication, I'd not even mind spending serious money for integrated Video!
Lense:
More than the sensor size & MP count in the camera, todays lenses are probably the most important aspect in the Quality of your pictures. If you don't mind getting an older model dslr, your money will be well spent using it for a better lense than for a newer model dslr. As a starter I suspect, one wouldn't have much budget. There is so much to consider in this department. First of all, I was torn between getting the T1i vs Canon EOS Rebel XSi and putting the money I save into a better lense. There are couple of reason why this is so: In terms of IQ, the XSi is one of the best in the Rebel Series out of canon. Despite its 12MP, it is either as good or better than the T1i in terms of IQ. Cramming 15MP into a slightly larger Sensor in the T1i has obviously led to Noise issues. If its just photograph's that you are going to take, I strongly recommend that you give the T1i a skip and get the XSi and a good lense. (In my case as I mentioned above, the Video was a deal maker too).
Coming to lenses, moving from the P&S obviously you'd like to have one super lense that can be used in all situations as was the case in your P&S. But here you have a lot more freedom (or rather some difficult choices to make initially). If you plan on using just one lense, then you must get a zoom lense with some range. Determine the crop factor of your P&S and get an idea of how much zoom you are used too, you could then look for an equivalent lense in the dSLR. Please note, here the zoom ranges interm of 2X, 3X or 12X etc... don't make sense. Its just the lense's max focal length divided by min focal length. Here the focal lengths are directly specified. Please note that the entry level dSLR also have a crop factor. google around and you'll get a good idea on this. One thing that must be pointed out is that, a zoom lense is always a compromise. If you don't mind carrying two lenses around, you could get the 18-55 & another lense for the longer range. This option will be both *less* expensive and better quality than a single super zoom. However for me, as I said numerous times already, size, weight et all matters a lot. So I decided to get the Canon 18-200mm. If there is too much to carry around, I might just end up not taking the equipment along. One more good thing about the super zoom is the amount of flexibility you get interms of composition.
With something like the 18-200, you can be well away from your subjects, which is great for Candid photos. Often the photos that I take of people (mostly my friends & kids in general), are best when they aren't aware that they are being photographed. The expressions are very natural and make great photos. So far I've not been disappointed with my choice. However in the lag side, I don't find the photos as sharp as they could be with say a prime. I'd highly recommend canon 50mm f/1.8 prime as well. At under $100, its one of the least expensive lenses but is very good in quality and especially good for indoor/low light shots. The one thing where I keep wishing the 18-200mm could've been better is in low light. f3.6-f5.4 is just not fast enough despite the IS. On hindsight I think I might as well have invested in a quicker lense, but hey, the prices are quite steep there.
One last thing to mention: The Tamron 18-270mm was stiff competition for my Canon 18-200mm. Not only does it have almost 30% more tele range, it was also less expensive than the Canon. It comes with a 6 year warranty in the US and it is a screaming buy over the Canon. However Tamron doesn't have many service centers in India (I thin it has only one), so I had to go with the Canon. Please note there are a lot of localites in blr that also service lenses. If you are not bothered about an authorized service center, you can still get it.
One more point is to be said about the 2 lense option. In India most places that you go to would probably be high on dust levels. So as such you need to be extra quick in changing lenses. Else you might have to clean the sensor manually very often. This was also a reason why I didn't go for the 2 lense option.
* filters & accessories:
I decided to get a clear filter to leave always on top of my 18-200mm, for protection. Hey your lense will be ruined even if you get a single scratch on it! So the clear filter will provide a level of protection. People have mixed opinions about this since many consider it as introducing cheap glass ontop of a good one (which is considered to bring down IQ). If you are getting one, get a good one although it might be a bit pricey rather than those that you'll find at half the price. I went for B+W. Will make a separate post of a list of things that I brought separately.
I also got a polarizer. It comes very usefull for landscape shots and removes reflections. This is a filter thats an absolute must have. For cleaning the lense I got a nikkon lense pen. There are lot of camera stores in B'lore where you also get something called Chmoise leather. This is good too. But still the lense pen is better.
Storage Cards:
Coming from the P&S world you might think that your not likely to exhaust a 8GB card in a single trip. But trust me you eventually will. I normally shoot in RAW+JPG. In raw, the T1i being a 15MP camera generates quite a large file for each shot. The largest I've seen is around 21MB! To my surprise I actually ran out of disk in a trip and had to hunt and delete images. I ended up getting the SanDisk 8 GB, Extreme III. I got 3 cards of these in an offer. Also make sure you are getting a card that is atleast as quick as your camera can write, you should be able to find that information from the many camera review sites you'll find around. (For me its always been dpreview.com). For a card reader, earlier I had an old Sandisk 8-in-1 Image Mate. Unfortunately, It didn't read SDHC. Being the same form factor, I assumed that it should be able to read it with a firmware upgrade, but later got to know that it just cant. My advice on a card reader is just get the cheapest one you can find. The technology changes so quickly, that if you invest in a more pricey one, chances are in a couple of years it'll be obsolete. I ended up getting one called 'Zippys' in ComputerWarehouse at B'lore for less than Rs 75 and it seemed to read SDHC! Its slow, but it works!.
Extra Battery pack:
From the P&S world, you'll find the dSLR battery life to be quite long. Nevertheless I recommend getting an additional battery for it. This again is in hindsight! Being conmpletely surprised by the long battery life, I didn't think I'll ever exhaust it in one trip. But what can I say, you keep learning new things every time. (This was in the same trip that I ran out of disk space as mentioned above! In this case I ran out of battery because I was doing a lot of reviewing and deleting photos).
Bag:
If you are looking for the so called "V type" bag in India, that just snuggly fits your camera with the lense attached, there are plenty of camera stores here in B'lore that sell those. They are good enough and are not as costly as the options in the US. If you plan on carrying lenses around you might want a bigger bag that holds it all. I have a crampler 5MDH as well. Its quite pricey, I wanted a non-camera bag sort of look. But in the end it was too big for my comfort, besides its just one lense for me, so I ended up buying a V type one in CameraCiti in B'lore. Thats the one I mostly use.
Tripod:
This is one thing where the price difference is huge in between the ones available. You find tripods under $20 at the same time you'll find mid range tripods at over $300. I'm leaving out the best of the range ones as I believe they'll be well out of budget for hobbyists such as myself moving form the P&S to the dSLR. Do yourself a favour and skip the low priced ones. I've had so many friends that brought those and found that they just didn't hold the camera steady enough and hence are not usable at all. Get one & Get one that will last and be useful. I ended up getting the Benro A-269M8 Travel Angel with a B-1 Ballhead. I've not used it a lot yet, but I've not been disappointed in the few occasions that I've used it. Seems very sturdy and comes with a neat bag to carry around. One thing that really very convinient about a P&S is that in low light situations, often you might still be able to take a good shot by placing your camera on a table or stand or whatever you can find at the moment rather than hand holding. With dSLR, depending on your lense you may not be able to do this. For instance my 18-200 lacks full time manual control, which means that its focus ring rotates on focus. So even when I'm able to find a place to place my camera on, still if the lenses touches an object, the camera will not be able to focus. Secondly, if you still manage to get spot where you can place you camera, you may not be able to get to the view finder. dSLRs now have a live-view mode which is similar to the PS showing what is being shot in the display, but this is pretty basic. However in such scenarios a swivel display is very helpfull. Unfortunately my T1i doesn't come with one. My A80's swivel display had saved me a lot of exercising when trying to take shots on timer and I miss it in my T1i almost every time I've tried to use live view.
One final advice: It takes quite some time for one to get used to the dSLRs controls. Plan on wasting your first few photo sessions & trips to equip yourself with some good technique and in getting comfortable with your dSLR.
Deciding on a dSLR has been a very difficult choice. The consumer is spoiled for choice. I nearly spent about a month surveying it all and finally ended up purchasing the Canon T1i.
Here a few pointers for those moving from the P&S range to dSLR. My main points of consideration where:
* Size. (Hey, no point in buying a dSLR if you find yourself avoiding it on casual trips because of its size)
* Image Quality. (A comparison at various ISO levels)
* Service options. (Its a big investment, this is definitely not an non-issue)
* Video
* lenses
* filters & accessories.
* bag
* a good tripod
Some elaboration:
Size: One of the coolest things about a P & S is that it would fit into your pocket and because it so small you don't mind carrying it out with friends on a trip. For dSLR, if you are going to the mid-range or pro ones, they are quite some baggage. Even entry level ones can be quite big compared to a dSLR. I choose the T1i over the Nikon because it was about 30% smaller and less heavy. For me size was a deal breaker issue. I know will not carry it around if its too big. One other thing to consider is that if the equipment looks intimidating, you may have places in India where they'll not let you take snaps. Once I'd borrowed my friends S2 IS and was shooting at Kanagadurga Temple (AP), out of nowhere a cop came and asked me to stop, saying that professional photography was disallowed. As long as I was shooting with the A80, there were no objections, because of its size, they think you are just normal tourist. I had to convince that guy with my id card to prove I wasn't a photographer!
Image Quality:
In this department, the Nikons win hands down. The difference is not too much. but still the Nikons are visibly better. Nevertheless for me the size swung my decision to the Canon T1i. (On hindsight now, though, I feel I shouldn't have compromised this. I find the T1i noise levels are often very high).
Service Centers:
I've narrated my experience with Canon above. So this was Canon for me hands down.
Video:
A small incident is worth a mention here:
I never did think I'll ever want to take video, but this changed after my nephew was born. I had a k500i mobile which has a pretty bad camera and Video. For over 3 years I ended up taking candid videos of him doing things right from Ages 3-5. Since the mobile was always there with me, I could just shoot when I pleased. Besides viewing it was also a breeze, you didn't have to setup a TV et all. When we used to wait for bus or something, often I'd play the videos and everyone in the family enjoyed watching. One fine day, I lost the phone. People at home teased me that it was about time I upgraded. But then later when it struck home that it was not just the phone that was gone but also all those videos, we were very sorry, for my nephew is now 7. See my point? Even though the phones video is pretty bad, just the availablity of the option makes you take videos. Later you might find that such things are priceless. So I was quite keen on having video on my DSLR too.
dSLRs have now begun to come with HiDef Video! The T1i represents a leap in technology, its integrated HiDef Video is another main factor that swung my decision to it. Beware though, the video has problems, It picks up lense focus noise which can be quite distracting. Also the Hidef recording speed is quite slow, so for anything that involves panning and some speed, it probably won't do. But nevertheless, the T1i was about a 100$ more expensive that the Xsi and I didn't want to loose the option of an integrated video recorder for $100. As I said, I don't like lugging a lot of baggage around (which I'd have to do if I got a cam corder. This is no match to a camcoder although the ability to change lenses might seem good. Hey but still, once in a while you might take off to a trip without plans to do video and you can never say when you'll find a few things worth preserving.) May be I'll not use the video, but still who knows? I didn't want to loose the option of video for a mere 4k rs extra. Hell, if my nephew's videos where any indication, I'd not even mind spending serious money for integrated Video!
Lense:
More than the sensor size & MP count in the camera, todays lenses are probably the most important aspect in the Quality of your pictures. If you don't mind getting an older model dslr, your money will be well spent using it for a better lense than for a newer model dslr. As a starter I suspect, one wouldn't have much budget. There is so much to consider in this department. First of all, I was torn between getting the T1i vs Canon EOS Rebel XSi and putting the money I save into a better lense. There are couple of reason why this is so: In terms of IQ, the XSi is one of the best in the Rebel Series out of canon. Despite its 12MP, it is either as good or better than the T1i in terms of IQ. Cramming 15MP into a slightly larger Sensor in the T1i has obviously led to Noise issues. If its just photograph's that you are going to take, I strongly recommend that you give the T1i a skip and get the XSi and a good lense. (In my case as I mentioned above, the Video was a deal maker too).
Coming to lenses, moving from the P&S obviously you'd like to have one super lense that can be used in all situations as was the case in your P&S. But here you have a lot more freedom (or rather some difficult choices to make initially). If you plan on using just one lense, then you must get a zoom lense with some range. Determine the crop factor of your P&S and get an idea of how much zoom you are used too, you could then look for an equivalent lense in the dSLR. Please note, here the zoom ranges interm of 2X, 3X or 12X etc... don't make sense. Its just the lense's max focal length divided by min focal length. Here the focal lengths are directly specified. Please note that the entry level dSLR also have a crop factor. google around and you'll get a good idea on this. One thing that must be pointed out is that, a zoom lense is always a compromise. If you don't mind carrying two lenses around, you could get the 18-55 & another lense for the longer range. This option will be both *less* expensive and better quality than a single super zoom. However for me, as I said numerous times already, size, weight et all matters a lot. So I decided to get the Canon 18-200mm. If there is too much to carry around, I might just end up not taking the equipment along. One more good thing about the super zoom is the amount of flexibility you get interms of composition.
With something like the 18-200, you can be well away from your subjects, which is great for Candid photos. Often the photos that I take of people (mostly my friends & kids in general), are best when they aren't aware that they are being photographed. The expressions are very natural and make great photos. So far I've not been disappointed with my choice. However in the lag side, I don't find the photos as sharp as they could be with say a prime. I'd highly recommend canon 50mm f/1.8 prime as well. At under $100, its one of the least expensive lenses but is very good in quality and especially good for indoor/low light shots. The one thing where I keep wishing the 18-200mm could've been better is in low light. f3.6-f5.4 is just not fast enough despite the IS. On hindsight I think I might as well have invested in a quicker lense, but hey, the prices are quite steep there.
One last thing to mention: The Tamron 18-270mm was stiff competition for my Canon 18-200mm. Not only does it have almost 30% more tele range, it was also less expensive than the Canon. It comes with a 6 year warranty in the US and it is a screaming buy over the Canon. However Tamron doesn't have many service centers in India (I thin it has only one), so I had to go with the Canon. Please note there are a lot of localites in blr that also service lenses. If you are not bothered about an authorized service center, you can still get it.
One more point is to be said about the 2 lense option. In India most places that you go to would probably be high on dust levels. So as such you need to be extra quick in changing lenses. Else you might have to clean the sensor manually very often. This was also a reason why I didn't go for the 2 lense option.
* filters & accessories:
I decided to get a clear filter to leave always on top of my 18-200mm, for protection. Hey your lense will be ruined even if you get a single scratch on it! So the clear filter will provide a level of protection. People have mixed opinions about this since many consider it as introducing cheap glass ontop of a good one (which is considered to bring down IQ). If you are getting one, get a good one although it might be a bit pricey rather than those that you'll find at half the price. I went for B+W. Will make a separate post of a list of things that I brought separately.
I also got a polarizer. It comes very usefull for landscape shots and removes reflections. This is a filter thats an absolute must have. For cleaning the lense I got a nikkon lense pen. There are lot of camera stores in B'lore where you also get something called Chmoise leather. This is good too. But still the lense pen is better.
Storage Cards:
Coming from the P&S world you might think that your not likely to exhaust a 8GB card in a single trip. But trust me you eventually will. I normally shoot in RAW+JPG. In raw, the T1i being a 15MP camera generates quite a large file for each shot. The largest I've seen is around 21MB! To my surprise I actually ran out of disk in a trip and had to hunt and delete images. I ended up getting the SanDisk 8 GB, Extreme III. I got 3 cards of these in an offer. Also make sure you are getting a card that is atleast as quick as your camera can write, you should be able to find that information from the many camera review sites you'll find around. (For me its always been dpreview.com). For a card reader, earlier I had an old Sandisk 8-in-1 Image Mate. Unfortunately, It didn't read SDHC. Being the same form factor, I assumed that it should be able to read it with a firmware upgrade, but later got to know that it just cant. My advice on a card reader is just get the cheapest one you can find. The technology changes so quickly, that if you invest in a more pricey one, chances are in a couple of years it'll be obsolete. I ended up getting one called 'Zippys' in ComputerWarehouse at B'lore for less than Rs 75 and it seemed to read SDHC! Its slow, but it works!.
Extra Battery pack:
From the P&S world, you'll find the dSLR battery life to be quite long. Nevertheless I recommend getting an additional battery for it. This again is in hindsight! Being conmpletely surprised by the long battery life, I didn't think I'll ever exhaust it in one trip. But what can I say, you keep learning new things every time. (This was in the same trip that I ran out of disk space as mentioned above! In this case I ran out of battery because I was doing a lot of reviewing and deleting photos).
Bag:
If you are looking for the so called "V type" bag in India, that just snuggly fits your camera with the lense attached, there are plenty of camera stores here in B'lore that sell those. They are good enough and are not as costly as the options in the US. If you plan on carrying lenses around you might want a bigger bag that holds it all. I have a crampler 5MDH as well. Its quite pricey, I wanted a non-camera bag sort of look. But in the end it was too big for my comfort, besides its just one lense for me, so I ended up buying a V type one in CameraCiti in B'lore. Thats the one I mostly use.
Tripod:
This is one thing where the price difference is huge in between the ones available. You find tripods under $20 at the same time you'll find mid range tripods at over $300. I'm leaving out the best of the range ones as I believe they'll be well out of budget for hobbyists such as myself moving form the P&S to the dSLR. Do yourself a favour and skip the low priced ones. I've had so many friends that brought those and found that they just didn't hold the camera steady enough and hence are not usable at all. Get one & Get one that will last and be useful. I ended up getting the Benro A-269M8 Travel Angel with a B-1 Ballhead. I've not used it a lot yet, but I've not been disappointed in the few occasions that I've used it. Seems very sturdy and comes with a neat bag to carry around. One thing that really very convinient about a P&S is that in low light situations, often you might still be able to take a good shot by placing your camera on a table or stand or whatever you can find at the moment rather than hand holding. With dSLR, depending on your lense you may not be able to do this. For instance my 18-200 lacks full time manual control, which means that its focus ring rotates on focus. So even when I'm able to find a place to place my camera on, still if the lenses touches an object, the camera will not be able to focus. Secondly, if you still manage to get spot where you can place you camera, you may not be able to get to the view finder. dSLRs now have a live-view mode which is similar to the PS showing what is being shot in the display, but this is pretty basic. However in such scenarios a swivel display is very helpfull. Unfortunately my T1i doesn't come with one. My A80's swivel display had saved me a lot of exercising when trying to take shots on timer and I miss it in my T1i almost every time I've tried to use live view.
One final advice: It takes quite some time for one to get used to the dSLRs controls. Plan on wasting your first few photo sessions & trips to equip yourself with some good technique and in getting comfortable with your dSLR.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home