Sunday, September 27, 2009

Kulir 100*

Watched this movie over the weekend. I was totally surprised in all dimensions (The movies itself, its director & the reviews it got). The movie did have severe flaws interms of plot & narration (we'll get to that), but some of the comments in the reviews it got are completely unwarranted.

For instance the NDTVMovies.com review states:
"The new tamil film, Kulir 100 is avoidable as it follows the same old drill." Oh! Please! When was the last time you saw a tamil movie that focused on a boarding school's dynamics? The last movie I saw of this genre was "Paneer Pushpangal", a 20 year old movie and that too focused on Love rather than the school although there were good glimpses of it. To my memory I've not seen any Tamil movie or for that matter any Indian movie that actually did put out the politics within a boarding school as well as this did.

At the outset let me state, that I grew up in one of the boarding schools in Ooty as well. There are several things which are a bit exaggerated here (the murder , the principal's daughter, the parties etc.. for instance), but mostly the rest is TRUE! The Students pack more clout than the teachers do and you typically can not really continue on if you are a misfit. The concept of SPL & ASPL and the politics around it is real, but the Students Council is not an official body (at least not in the school, I studied). But nevertheless informally the Seniors did rule and it was pretty much sacrilege to go against them. You'd be crazy to go against them and you'd be beaten up pretty bad. The movie also got one thing right, the guys in leadership positions are really capable super achievers, both studies wise & leadership wise. Its not the normal kind that you find around in schools that bears the title of a class leader & simply notes the names of students who talked and gives to teacher. The environment that prevails is much more intense than what you'd see in most colleges around. Unfortunately for Anita Udeep, not many people in TN know about this and to them the movie would look as if it was completely unreal hence the bad reviews. (example and yet another here). Couple that with the confusion in the plot and altogether they pretty much nail the movie into its coffin. The movie chose to highlight the issues that a misfit faces & dwels primarily on the negative side of the students council, While in truth there are also very strong good points as well, but the movie didn't dwell on those and that is understandable (since its only controvorsial things that attract the mundane crowd).


Its quite clear that Anita Udeep is talented. The movie had me identifying very much with my schooling days. She, would have done well to just focus on the school rather than trying to attach a prefix and a suffix to the school episode. This was essentially the fatal problem with the movie. The mom/dad issues, just don't fuse nicely with the school part and after the school episode, the suffix of the mom dying just didn't strike a cord at all. It seems to be so separate that its like oil over water. This inturn leads to people finding the overall story line confusing as to where the director intended to take it. A flaw such as that is certain to break a movie. However going about calling it "usual" etc...is just a wrong review.

After a good buildup in the schools issues, it was a big let down to just see the hero finish it all in one night. That kind of scattered away the pace that was built up and just lacked enough of pop to justify the build up. It would have been nice had the director dropped of the mom/dad issues and extended on aftermath of the buildup rather than a one night stand. In all this review was the only one that I found to be accurate and nailed the issues exactly. I've to finish saying the same lines that the reviewer there had stated:
"While Anitha Udeep’s talent is evident in most parts, she has to be clearer on what and how she wants to convey".